Appendix to the full-portfolio lift
Red Cottage, November 2026

The 206 homes, seasoned and newer.

Every home here has at least one guest stay, completed or booked, on or after September 1, 2026. Homes with none are excluded. Every home in the estimate, split into the 98 seasoned homes (first guest stay before January 1, 2025) and the 108 newer homes (started in 2025 or 2026). Gross rent is for the trailing 12 months, October 24, 2025 to October 23, 2026.

The two groups side by side

GroupHomesAvg bedroomsAvg gross rent per homeGross rent per bedroom
Seasoned983.9$53,891$13,972
Newer, all1083.5$33,579$9,619
Newer, in service the full 12 months433.5$41,413$11,951

The 65 newer homes not in the last row started during the window, so they show less than 12 months of rent. Five of them have their first guest stay booked for November or December 2026, so they show no rent yet. Like every home in this list, each has a guest stay booked on or after September 1, 2026. Compare the seasoned homes to the third row for a like-for-like view.

Back to the full-portfolio lift

Seasoned homes (98)

In service before 2025. Sorted by gross rent over the last 12 months.

HomeBedroomsFirst guest stayMonths in windowGross rent, last 12 monthsIn October snapshot
Birch & Buck4Oct 202212$191,588Yes
Spirit Cabin3Jul 202312$186,838Yes
Whimsy Woods4Jul 202212$167,466Yes
West Kill Farmhouse5Sep 202312$149,490Yes
The Rye House4Jul 202412$130,762Yes
DoodletwnLdgeMAIN5Jul 202412$130,109Yes
Falls Road5Jun 202312$130,034Yes
Casa Manzara5Nov 202412$122,802Yes
Red Rock Summit4Nov 202312$120,928Yes
Rock 'n' House4Sep 202312$115,150Yes
Valley View5Jul 202412$114,587Yes
Moon Meadow Farmhs5Oct 202312$111,149Yes
Stowe WoodsChalet4Dec 202412$100,710Yes
Hilltop4Dec 202212$90,748Yes
Hudson Valley Hideaw5Nov 202412$88,066Yes
Sunflower Farmhouse6Jan 202412$87,930Yes
Highland Haus3Dec 202412$86,571Yes
River Cottage3May 202212$83,561Yes
Rad Studio5Feb 202412$82,549Yes
Bay Beach House3May 202412$78,898
Hemlock Cliffhouse3Jul 202312$78,701Yes
Belleayre View3Mar 201912$76,732Yes
Meeker Hill House3Jan 202312$76,289Yes
DoodletwnLdgeFULL9Oct 202412$74,816Yes
Hidden Ridge4Sep 202312$66,536Yes
Post Haus2Oct 202312$66,520Yes
Milan Hill AFrame4Dec 201912$63,796Yes
Overlook Meadow3Dec 202312$63,492Yes
Mohawk Mountain Retr5Aug 202212$62,731Yes
The Treehaus3Oct 202312$60,738Yes
Hillside Haven4Jul 202212$60,142Yes
The Homestead - Full14May 201912$60,005Yes
Little River_Co2Apr 202312$59,930Yes
Casa Magda4Jul 202112$59,915Yes
The Gables8Apr 201912$56,841Yes
Hidden Pond3May 202212$56,441Yes
Winterberry Farmh4Nov 202412$56,221Yes
Silver Ridge4Dec 202112$53,173Yes
Blue Mountain Cabin4May 202412$50,600Yes
Belleayre Barn3Dec 202312$49,930Yes
DoodletwnLdgeCABN4Jul 202312$49,801Yes
Chalet des Collines4Jul 202112$48,850Yes
Rockwell Haus5Feb 202412$48,442Yes
Mountaintop VIEW3Dec 202412$47,926Yes
Clancy House4Jul 202312$47,525Yes
Sugar Mountain House4Jun 202412$46,625Yes
Willow Brook4Dec 202312$45,527Yes
The Aster Chalet4Jul 202412$44,615Yes
Spruce Cove Cabin2Oct 202312$43,015Yes
Owl Brook4Sep 202412$40,747Yes
Navywood3Jul 202212$39,799Yes
Trail's End2Apr 202412$39,128Yes
Wildcat Mtn Cabin2Mar 201912$39,069Yes
Kaaterskill Mtn5Oct 202412$37,599Yes
Malden Sur Hudson4Nov 202212$37,108Yes
Onyx A Frame3Mar 202412$36,561Yes
Nature’s Edge3Jul 202412$35,886Yes
Tanner Farmhouse3Sep 202312$35,725Yes
Coal Cabin2Apr 201912$35,244Yes
Fulton House4Dec 202012$34,784Yes
Nordic Cabin3Jun 202312$33,279Yes
Tamarack House2Apr 202012$32,943Yes
Le Petit Cottage3Dec 201912$31,570Yes
Lilac Hill4Dec 202112$31,383Yes
Kripplebush Hollow3Jul 202212$31,127Yes
Derry Woods Cabin3Oct 202412$31,109Yes
The Iron Ore Cabin3Oct 202412$29,949Yes
Myers Ridge5Jun 202312$28,837Yes
The Homestead Main11Jun 201912$28,755Yes
Narrowsburg Chalet3Oct 202412$27,985Yes
Knickerbocker Knoll3Oct 202112$27,579Yes
Half Moon Mtn House4Aug 202412$27,019Yes
Grove House3Aug 202212$26,476Yes
The Barn @Doodletown4Jul 202412$26,205Yes
Cedar Brook Cabin2Oct 202312$26,082Yes
Riverside Cabin FULL6Sep 202312$25,989Yes
Fern Hollow2Nov 202412$25,487Yes
Hudson Victorian2May 202312$24,828Yes
Meadow Top Cotta3Oct 202212$24,444Yes
Hemlock Hill Barn3Apr 202412$24,289Yes
Brookside Manor4Sep 201912$23,972Yes
Mountaintop LOFT1Nov 202412$23,653Yes
Owl's Perch3Aug 202412$23,604Yes
Chestnut Ridge Cabin3Nov 202412$23,273Yes
Woodland Manor3Oct 202412$22,688Yes
Sleepy Hollow Lake3Jul 202412$20,135Yes
Steepletop Lodge4Nov 202312$16,462Yes
Five Acres Farm5May 202212$15,856Yes
Phoebe's Nest4Feb 202012$12,947Yes
Reservoir House3Apr 201912$11,891Yes
Riverside Cabin MAIN3Sep 202312$10,674
SaltBox Lodge4Dec 202412$10,612
Hamlin House5Apr 201912$10,469Yes
Silver Birch DOWN4Aug 202412$9,099Yes
Artist's Edge3May 202312$8,763Yes
Woodlands3May 201912$7,465Yes
Stonebridge Hideaway3Feb 202412$4,561Yes
Archways4Mar 202212$2,436

Newer homes (108)

Started in 2025 or 2026. Sorted by gross rent over the last 12 months. "Months in window" is how many full months of the 12 the home was live.

HomeBedroomsFirst guest stayMonths in windowGross rent, last 12 monthsIn October snapshot
Graybarn at Copake5Aug 202512$185,222
Wildewood4Nov 202511$142,114
Bluff at Eagle Hollo3Nov 202511$120,914
Zenbrook4Jan 202512$108,194Yes
Sunset Lakehouse4Jan 202512$91,823
Taghkanic House4Jul 202512$90,983
Peak Views in Jay5Nov 202511$90,411
Twin Pond Ridge5Mar 20266$89,330
Haven in the Hollow4Nov 202511$87,456
Above and Beyond3Nov 202511$80,584
Lotus Lodge5Oct 202512$80,058
Stonybrook5Dec 202510$78,644
Stonehaven Catskills3Mar 202512$69,590
Shell House4Aug 202512$66,876
Maple Branch Manor7Dec 20259$66,703
ESKape Manor3Mar 202512$65,429
Manderley House3May 202512$63,392
Lockwood Lodge4May 20265$60,624
Lakeville Lodge3Nov 202510$60,042
MORO Cabin2Mar 20267$57,649
La Finca4Oct 202512$57,236
Phoenicia Farmhouse3Jul 202512$55,307
Endless Meadow House3Aug 202512$53,375
Deerfoot Inn4May 202512$53,023
Celestial Cabin3Nov 202511$52,511
Stony Clove Cabin3Oct 202512$51,199
Harlem Val. Hideout3Mar 202512$48,945
Hist. Hobble Inn3Dec 202510$47,596
The Bunker2Nov 202511$46,724
Break House3Nov 202511$46,671
Catskills Dream Lake2Dec 202510$45,873
Enchanted Views3Nov 202511$44,881
The Waterfall House4Oct 202512$40,675
Hot Toddy3Nov 202510$38,927
Redwood Manor4Mar 20267$38,864
The Whistling Oak3Oct 202512$36,829
Galleon's Lap3May 20265$33,744
Mohonk View3Feb 202512$33,273
Hist. Hobble InnLoft1Nov 202511$32,679
Mountaintop FULL4Jan 202512$31,665
Tetra A-Frame4Nov 202510$31,204
Alpine View4Apr 202512$30,943
Sunflake4Dec 20259$30,055
Pucky Pines4May 202512$29,539
Butterfly Cottage3Jul 202512$29,434
Shandelee Brook Hous4Jul 202512$29,425
Cabin by Clover Pond2Oct 202512$27,659
Maplewood Meadow3May 202512$26,858
Crossbridge - Full6Jun 202512$26,395
Abbey Road Farmhouse7Jan 202512$26,060
Meadow Top Cabin1Feb 202512$25,723
Luna House3Dec 20259$24,274
Zenwood Manor3May 202512$24,028
High Meadow House4Oct 202512$24,014
Riverbend3Oct 202512$22,800
The Bellows House5Jan 20269$22,231
Beaverbrook2Jun 20263$21,881
Skyhawk Cabin4Feb 202512$21,416
The Long View (Leeds LH)3May 202512$21,278
Wild Sage Cabin2Apr 20265$21,150
17 Pines2May 202512$20,579
Duck Pond Lodge3Dec 20259$20,116
Alpine Condo3Dec 202510$19,394
Alpine Nest3Jun 20264$17,858
Alpine Falls Chalet4Feb 20268$17,812
Jay Cloud Cabin3Aug 202512$17,812
The Sagewood Retreat4Mar 20266$17,761
Cragsmoor Cottage3Apr 20265$17,678
Manor Cottage3Jun 20263$17,378
Gardiner Retreat3Oct 202512$17,269
Crossbridge - Main4May 202512$16,913
Carrotflower Farmhou5Jan 20269$16,799
Edgewood Station5Aug 20262$16,774
The Makely House7Feb 20268$16,134
Boulder Den3Jul 20263$15,566
Riverlight Retreat4Sep 20261$13,957
Forest Cottage1Jul 202512$13,187
Troutwood Chalet3Oct 202512$12,939
The Countryman4Aug 20262$12,163
Camelback Splash & Ski3Jun 20264$11,908
The Blankenburg Hous3Aug 202512$11,016
Red Hill House3Oct 202512$10,987
Dunn Brook Lakehouse3Jun 202512$10,678
Edgewood Lakehouse3May 20265$10,221
Sanctuary Barn2May 20265$8,750
Frog Hollow3Aug 20262$7,827
Stag Hill House3Jun 20264$7,295
Drift House3Jul 20263$7,117
Woodland Modern5Sep 20261$7,052
Deer Hill Cabin3Jul 20263$6,405
Hapgood Hollow3Aug 20262$6,384
La Estancia3Aug 20262$6,035
Roxbury Main Back #11Feb 20267$5,935
Boulder Cove Retreat5Aug 20262$4,616
Fernbrook5Sep 20261$4,500
Barclay House6Oct 2026<1$3,999
White Gates Chalet4Sep 2026<1$3,947
Pond Hollow3Oct 2026<1$3,463
Dutch on Depot3Oct 2026<1$2,385
Hardenburgh House4Oct 2026<1$1,868
Whaler's Landing3Oct 2026<1$1,668
Timberline House3Oct 2026<1$1,281
Cardinal Crossing4Jun 202512$705
56 Trout Town3BED3Dec 2026<1$0
Argyll House6Dec 2026<1$0
Pennybrook Cottage2Dec 2026<1$0
Triangle A Frame2Dec 2026<1$0
Summit Cabin4Nov 2026<1$0
Notes. Gross rent is the accommodation amount before OTA commission and excludes cleaning fees and tax. Source: Beyond Pricing reservation export read October 23, 2026, accepted guest stays only, with each booking spread evenly across its nights. First guest stay is the earliest guest stay in the export. The "In October snapshot" column marks the 95 same-store homes in the October revenue snapshot, which were the homes with two full years of history. 94 of the 98 seasoned homes are in that snapshot, and 1 newer home is.